The Free Sample Trap: Why On-the-Spot Feedback Tells You What People Think You Want to Hear
Six years ago we created a comic strip about a couple trying a free product sample at a shopping centre. At the
July 20, 2026
Create effective
product claims and taglines
using implicit research
Testing the emotional associations with claims and taglines, and their believability.
When we test claims and taglines what are we testing?
A claim or tagline is a powerful tool that can make or break a brand’s success in the marketplace. We present them textually or within the context of a visual, such as a logo or campaign theme.
They serve as a concise and memorable way for a brand to communicate its value proposition to potential customers.
We can test a set of claims or taglines shown in isolation. We reveal which one delivers the desired effect better and why. We can also compare them with those from previous campaigns or those of competitors.
Claims and taglines can create a strong emotional connection with consumers and help to build a loyal customer base. This is why we use implicit techniques to understand the emotional and functional impact of the claim or tagline. This impact should affect the brand and its purchase intent.
They can also communicate the brand’s essence, values, and unique selling proposition, and highlight its unique benefits, positioning, or personality. This is why we also measure the believability of claims and taglines. We wish to know if the target audience feel it is a believable or plausible statement about the brand.
Why is an implicit response great for claims and tagline testing?
The claims a brand makes can either be the truth, half-truth (and hence half-lie) or lies. Some solid research now shows that only truthful claims, claims that are perceived to be plausible and believable, can have a positive impact on the brand (de Jong1 , Huluba1 & Beldad, 2020). Hence, believability of claims needs to be assessed before being used. It is also the case that the emotional and functional associations people have with a claim should be measured as its intended effects on the brand could be way off.
Being unique and differentiated is a critical factor when creating effective claims and taglines for advertising campaigns. It’s not enough to simply offer a quality product or service. Brands must also be able to stand out from their competitors too.
A unique and differentiated claim or tagline should also be memorable to consumers. By using catchy phrases, creative imagery, and unique messaging, brands can create a lasting impression in the minds of consumers. For example, M&M’s “Melts in Your Mouth, Not in Your Hands” tagline has been used for decades and has become a staple of the brand’s marketing efforts. The tagline is memorable, catchy, and effectively communicates the product’s value proposition to consumers.
Back Up Claims and Taglines with Evidence to be ‘Believable’
Consumers are becoming ever more discerning and savvy, and they can easily see through any claim that lacks evidence or factual support.
Therefore, it’s essential for brands to ensure that their claims and taglines are not only unique and engaging but also believable.
Measure the Emotional Response to Your Product Claims
Claims and taglines featured on marketing materials and packaging say much about a brand. They can effectively communicate the brand’s essence, values, and unique selling proposition. This in turn builds brand awareness among potential customers, and differentiates the brand from competitors.
Split Second Research can test new and existing claims, as well as those of competitors, to determine their effects on consumer perception and intent to purchase. These tests can reveal the emotions that consumers associate with a claim. They also reveal something about the ownership of a claim. This means whether the brand owns the claim or if it is misattributed to a competitor.
References
de Jong, M. D., Huluba, G., & Beldad, A. D. (2020). Different shades of greenwashing: Consumers’ reactions to environmental lies, half-lies, and organizations taking credit for following legal obligations. Journal of Business and Technical Communication, 34(1), 38-76.
Updated July 2024 by Dr Eamon Fulcher PhD
See our brand assets implicit case study
Applications
Use our technology, founded in consumer neuroscience, to understand the effectiveness of your product claims
- Claims on packaging and in advertising
- Brand taglines
- Plausibility & believability of a tagline
- Do you own your tagline?
Great things can happen in a split-second
Fill out an enquiry form and start to see what we can do for your brand.
Alternatively, please email Geraldine Trufil at info@splitsecondresearch.co.uk
or call: +44 (0) seven eight seven 8 four double five 9 double four
Start A Conversation
Complete an enquiry form to arrange a meeting with us:
Our blog
Your Customers Know More Than They Can Tell You
Every year, thousands of new products launch on the back of research that said they would succeed. Concept tests came back positive. Focus groups nodded along. Survey respondents said,
July 16, 2026
You think ads don’t work on you. That’s exactly the problem.
75% of people asked to rate an ad, claim advertising doesn’t affect them.
So what exactly are they rating? And why are we
June 2, 2026